17 Modern Chicken Casseroles That’ll Make Your Mom Jealous

No offense to your mom’s chicken casserole… if the memory were really that scarring, you probably wouldn’t be searching for chicken casserole recipes to cook for dinner tonight, would you? But those classic casserole recipes from our childhoods need an update, which is why we’ve rounded up 22 casserole recipes that you can actually get excited to make.

There’s a reason why busy chefs have been putting chicken bakes on the table weeknight after weeknight for all these years: putting one together is as simple as dump n’ bake, they often make use of pantry staples, and they fill your belly fast. These recipes are also really, really good. Filled with mouthwateringly modern twists like enchilada sauce, teriyaki, butternut squash, quinoa, wild rice, stuffing, zucchini, fajita veggies, buffalo chicken and more, these chicken casseroles will make your mom say, “Why didn’t I think of that?”

1. Chicken Tomato Pasta Bake

This chicken tomato casserole with three kinds of cheese and fresh spinach will leave you full in the best way.

2. Chicken Alfredo Baked Ziti

Chicken Alfredo and baked ziti are already two of your family’s favorite dinners, so we had a big fat Italian wedding and married the two dishes into one bubbling casserole that’s ready in less than an hour.

3. Chicken Parmesan Casserole

How do you make tasty chicken parm easier to feed a whole bunch of people? Turn it into a casserole!

4. Salsa Chicken Casserole

This riff on burritos take chicken, salsa, corn, rice, and Tex-Mex seasoning and turns it into a casserole-rific dinner.

5. Chicken Pot Pie

Chicken pot pie is really just a creamy chicken casserole with a crust. Our recipe uses prepared pie crust so you don’t have to work any harder than you would for a casserole, but you still get that buttery, flaky pastry shell.

6. Teriyaki Chicken and Rice Casserole

We don’t usually associate Asian flavors with casseroles, but this one from Emily Bites with veggies, chicken breasts, brown rice, pineapple, and teriyaki sauce really works!

7. Layered BBQ Chicken Sweet Potato Enchilada Casserole

BBQ and enchilada sauce make these layers of sweet potato, chicken, and corn tortillas from Ambitious Kitchen positively drip with flavor.

8. Chicken and Potatoes with Garlic Parmesan Cream Sauce

Forget side dishes, this chicken bake from Damn Delicious is a whole meal in one casserole dish. She roasted crispy chicken thighs, spinach, and potatoes in a luscious cream sauce.

9. Chicken and Wild Rice Casserole with Butternut Squash and Cranberries

Finally, a casserole that’s not a total gut-buster! Well Plated has created a hearty and healthy chicken and wild rice bake with earthy add-ins like butternut squash and cranberries that make this a perfect one to bookmark for the holidays.

10. Asparagus, Chicken, and Quinoa Bake

The Creative Bite really did get creative with her chicken casserole, adding nutritious asparagus and quinoa. Leeks, bacon, and extra sharp white cheddar add so much punch, you won’t believe how light it is.

11. Creamy Swiss Chicken Bake

It doesn’t get any more rich and creamy than this no-stress meal from Lil’ Luna. Not into Swiss? She says you can sub mozzarella!

12. “Cracked Out” Chicken and Rice Bake

This casserole’s secret weapon? Plain Chicken uses leftover rotisserie chicken and a can of cream of chicken soup to get this dish ready for the oven in five minutes flat!

13. Chicken Noodle Casserole

Kleinworth & Co. have a winning formula on their hands: egg noodles + corn + peas + bacon bits + french fried onions + cream of chicken soup = comfort food, fast!

14. Chicken Tetrazzini

It might sound like an old Italian dish, but this all-American casserole is actually named after opera star Luisa Tetrazzini. In Shugary Sweets’ version, spaghetti, chicken breasts, and cheese are baked in a white wine cream sauce. Picky eaters will be delighted that she leaves out the classic mushrooms — but if you’re a fungi fanatic, you can always put them back in!

15. Chicken and Stuffing Casserole

Why oh why do we only eat stuffing once a year? The Seasoned Mom has the answer: don’t!

16. Chicken Cordon Bleu Casserole

Tasty Kitchen takes the fancy-pants dish and turns it into a casserole with shredded chicken (leftovers are OK!), chopped ham, deli slices of Swiss cheese, and a crispy breadcrumb topping.

17. Buffalo Ranch Chicken Bake

We know you drooled over our grilled cheesy buffalo chicken, buffalo chicken dip, and buffalo cauliflower bites… next up, Happy Go Lucky Blog’s buffalo ranch chicken bake is yet another way to enjoy those game-time flavors.

Now go forth with your casserole dish and make your mom jealous proud! Got a dog-eared chicken casserole that’s not on this list? We want to hear about it!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *